Your browser is out of date or unsupported. As a result, some elements of this website may not be fully functional. For the best possible user experience, it is recommended that you use the latest version of Chrome, Firefox or Microsoft Edge.
TV Edwards Solicitors Logo
Call us on: 020 3440 8000
  • About Us
    • Whitechapel Office
    • Clapham Junction Office
    • What Our Clients Say
    • Cybercrime and Fraud Warning
    • Pricing
    • Make a Secure Payment
  • Services
    • You & Your Family You & Your Family
      • Family and Children Law
      • Wills and Probate
      • Personal Injury
      • Dispute Resolution
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Community Care
      • Criminal Defence
    • You & Your Property You & Your Property
      • Residential Property
      • Property Disputes
      • Housing
    • You & Your Business You & Your Business
      • Commercial Property
      • Commercial Litigation
      • Business Crime and Fraud
      • Alcohol & Entertainment Licensing
    • _
  • Our People
    • Partners and Management Team
    • Family and Children
    • Property
    • Wills and Probate
    • Court of Protection
    • Criminal Defence
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Personal Injury
    • Alcohol and Entertainment Licensing
    • Mental Health
    • Community Care
    • Housing
  • News and Blogs
  • Careers
TV Edwards Solicitors Logo
  • You & Your Family
    • Family and Children Law
    • Wills and Probate
    • Personal Injury
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Mental Health
    • Court of Protection
    • Community Care
    • Criminal Defence
  • You & Your Property
    • Residential Property
    • Property Disputes
    • Housing
  • You & Your Business
    • Commercial Property
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Business Crime and Fraud
    • Alcohol & Entertainment Licensing
  • About Us
    • Whitechapel Office
    • Clapham Junction Office
    • What Our Clients Say
    • Pricing
    • Make a Secure Payment
  • Our People
    • Community Care
    • Court of Protection
    • Criminal Defence
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Family and Children
    • Housing
    • Alcohol and Entertainment Licensing
    • Mental Health
    • Partners and Management Team
    • Personal Injury
    • Wills and Probate
    • Property
    • Support Team
  • News and Blogs
  • Careers
Call us on: 020 3440 8000
×
  • Divorce
    • Divorce process
    • Finances
    • Civil partnerships
    • Child arrangements
  • Children
    • Child arrangements
    • Social services
    • Adoption
    • Special guardianship
    • Relocation
    • Abduction
  • Modern Parenting
    • Surrogacy
    • Fertility
    • Donor conception
    • Co-parenting
    • Adoption
  • Unmarried couples
    • Pre nups, post nups and pre partnership agreements
    • Cohabitation agreements
    • Separation
    • Finances for children
  • Domestic abuse
    • Domestic abuse
    • Forced marriage
    • FGM
×

Start typing to search.

    ×
    TV Edwards Solicitors Logo

    020 3440 8000

    enquiries@tvedwards.com

    Find us at Whitechapel and Clapham Junction

    Contact Us

    Please enter your first name(s).
    Please enter your surname.
    Please enter a valid email address.
    Please enter your contact number.
    Please select an option.
    Please enter a message.

    We’ll only use this information to handle your enquiry and we won’t share it with any third parties. For more details see our Privacy Policy.

    TV EDWARDS SOLICITORS LLP

    Legal Test for Leave to Apply to Discharge an SGO

    In the recent case of Re: M (Special Guardianship Order: Leave to Apply to Discharge) [2021] EWCA Civ 442, the...

    Back to News & Blogs 3rd December 2021

    Comment Icon
    TV Edwards Blog
    Blog Family

    In the recent case of Re: M (Special Guardianship Order: Leave to Apply to Discharge) [2021] EWCA Civ 442, the court considered the legal test for leave to apply to discharge an SGO. The Court approved the two-stage approach decided in the established case of Warwickshire, determined that a change in circumstances was necessary but not in itself sufficient and that the Court needed to weigh the welfare of the child with the prospects of success.

    This appeal concerned the construction of Section 14(d) of the Children Act 1989 in the context of an appreciation of nature and affect of SGO. The appeal also concerned the circumstances in which an application for a Child Arrangements Order can be summarily dismissed.

    Background

    The proceedings concerned a boy ‘C’ aged 9 in October 2016. Proceedings were issued due to a breakdown of his mother’s mental health. He moved to live with his maternal grandmother and her partner (“the grandparents”). The mother was assessed by a Consultant Psychiatrist as having an emotionally unstable personality disorder and it was recommended that she required long term therapy, the time frame of which was over 12-18months. At the time of the assessment the mother did not recognise the need for the work to be undertaken. It was agreed that the mother when well was able to parent C to a good enough standard however the concern was that when she was unwell, she could not meet C’s needs. The outcome of the care proceedings was a special guardianship order being made in the grandparents’ favour without opposition. It was accompanied by written agreement which was approved by the Local Authority and the Court. The agreement which described itself as unpinning the SGO spelled out how decisions for the child would be taken and how information would be exchanged. There were also several directions made setting out the contact arrangements so that C could still retain a relationship with his mother.

    In February 2020, the mother applied for leave to make an application to discharge the SGO with a view to C returning to her care. She made a further application for contact with C, making an application for a child arrangements order. The mother submitted that her mental health was much improved however her application was opposed by the Grandparents on the basis that it was not in C’s best interests to have a change in carer. The local authority expressed concern about the SGO being revoked and the instability this could cause for the child.

    In giving judgement the Court of Appeal considered the law in respect of special guardianship orders, commenting that the purpose of a special guardianship order is to achieve permanence for the child. The objective of planning for permanence is therefore to ensure that children have a secure, stable, and loving family to support them through childhood and beyond and to give them a sense of security, continuity, and commitment, identity and belonging.

    In terms of discharge or variation of a Special Guardianship Order, the Court turned to Section 14(d) of the 1989 Act which is concerned with the manner in which Special Guardianship Orders can be varied or discharged. A parent seeking to discharge a Special Guardianship Order requires leave of the court which can only be given if the court is satisfied that there has been a significant change in circumstances. The court looked at what was meant by a ‘significant change in circumstances’ and cited the case of Re: G (Special Guardianship Order) [2010] EWCA Civ 300, in which it was said that when considering an application for leave to discharge an SGO, the Court should follow the two stage approach applicable to applications for leave to revoke a Placement Order set out in M v Warwickshire County Council [2007] EWCA Civ 1084. The first stage of the test is that there must have been a significant change in circumstances. Significant simply means ‘considerable, noteworthy or important’. The second stage is that there must be a real prospect of success. It was concluded that a change in circumstance is likely to be intertwined with the prospects of success, and the greater the prospects of success, the more cogent the welfare arguments must be if leave is to be refused. The court went on to say that the assessment concerns the affect on the child’s welfare of the application to discharge the special guardianship order being heard or not heard, the question of whether it is in the child’s interest for the SGO to be discharged only arises if leave is granted at which welfare is undoubtedly paramount.

    The mother in this case had also made an application for contact in respect of C. The judged at first instance not only refused her application for leave to apply to discharge the SGO, she also concluded it was not in C’s best interests for there to be a contact order. The Court of Appeal determined that such applications should not be considered an abuse of process as a matter of principle. A parent has a right to issue an application for Child Arrangements Order (other than a lives with order) and when issued the Court must consider the application on its merits. The court concluded that that the appeal should succeed for several reasons including that the test that the judge applied for change in circumstances was too high as she considered that all of the issues with led to the making of the SGO needed to have been resolved and the judge’s conclusion followed from the test that she applied. The Court of Appeal also considered that the judge had not considered the issue of welfare correctly. The appeal was therefore allowed, and the previous orders were set aside. The mother was granted leave to apply to discharge the SGO and her application for contact was also restored.

    Alpa Ghelani is an Associate solicitor in the Family department at TV Edwards. She has broad professional experience in relation to children law and special guardianship cases. Contact Alpa on alpa.ghelani@tvedwards.com or 020 3440 8184 for advice on a related query.

    More Articles

    Article Image

    Important guidance on seeking a stay of an order pending the hearing of a permission to appeal application

    6th February 2023
    Article Image

    Wilkins v Serco

    26th January 2023
    Article Image

    The top five things you need to know about deputyship

    12th January 2023
    Article Image

    Life as a trainee solicitor at TV Edwards LLP

    9th January 2023
    Article Image

    Updates to the police bail regime – how long can I be kept on police bail?

    6th January 2023
    Article Image

    When couples separate, what are the legalities around future use of their frozen embryos?

    14th December 2022
    All Articles 

    Contact Us

    Call: 020 3440 8000|View our Whitechapel Office|View our Clapham Junction Office

    Call: 020 3440 8000
    Whitechapel Office
    Clapham Junction Office

    Cyber Essentials Accreditation Logo
    Lexcel Logo
    The Legal 500 – The Clients Guide to Law Firms
    Chambers 2021 Logo

    © 2023 TV Edwards LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (465533) and is a Limited Liability Partnership registered in England and Wales number 0C325696. Details of the SRA Code of Conduct can be found at sra.org.uk. Registered name: TV Edwards LLP. Registered Office: 35-37 Mile End Road, London, E1 4TP.

    TV Edwards Solicitors Logo

    Contact Us

    Call us on: 020 3440 8000

    View our Whitechapel office

    View our Clapham Junction office


    • Quick Links
      • Pricing
      • Pay Online
      • Careers with TV Edwards
    • Insights
      • Blogs
    • Regulatory
      • Legal Disclaimer
      • Terms of Business
      • Accessibility
      • Privacy Policy – Website Users
      • Privacy Policy – General
      • Cookies
      • Complaints Procedure

    Find us on:


    TV Edwards Solicitors Logo
    • Divorce
    • Children
    • Modern Parenting
    • Unmarried couples
    • Domestic abuse
    © 2022 TV Edwards LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (465533) and is a Limited Liability Partnership registered in England and Wales number 0C325696. Details of the SRA Code of Conduct can be found at sra.org.uk. Registered name: TV Edwards LLP. Registered Office: 35-37 Mile End Road, London, E1 4TP.
    Use of Cookies

    Our website requires the use of cookies. Enabling all cookies makes sure the website works as smoothly as possible, and also helps us to improve it. Some cookies are activated by default but tracking cookies aren't switched on without your consent.

    For our full policy, visit our cookies page.


    Using this tool will set a cookie on your device to remember your preferences.

    Necessary

    Necessary cookies enable core functionality of the website, including security, SRA Regulationand reCAPTCHA form verifications. It is possible to disable these cookies in your browser settings, but this could affect the functionality of the website.


    Recommended
    Off On

    Recommended cookies improve your experience of our site by helping to display our latest client reviews and embedded maps of our office locations. You can find full details on Google's privacy policy here.


    Analytics
    Off On

    We'd like to use analytics services provided by Google Analytics, Microsoft Clarity and Ruler Analytics to collect anonymous information from our visitors. The data we collect will help us to improve our website and services. Learn more about how we use these services and our commitment to safeguarding data in our Cookie Policy.

    Settings Save & Close